October

Rail Theory Forecasts™ LLC

Annual Publication

North American Rail Car Market

Products & Services Railroads Return Home Suppliers Press Releases Recent Magazine Articles Contact Us

 

Car Type Checkpoints

Boxcars: Market dead
Covered Hoppers:
Cement Cars: Surplus cars are available P&W Yard in Albany Oregon
Grain Cars Grain traffic is back to normal levels and the fleet should be fully utilized soon.
Plastic Pellet & DDG Cars: Car surpluses should disappear in 2010, but orders for new cars may not come as fast.
F Type Flatcars: New car market is dead and will remain dead until housing recovers
V Autorack Flatcars: Sales of new autos and trucks is still down and no demand for new railcars
Intermodal:Traffic is down, surplus cars abound, market may not recover before 2012
GB Gons: Demand for new cars related to replacements only
GT Coal Gons: Orders for new cars will be very soft for a while

OT Hoppers:Orders for new cars will be very soft for a while
RD Hoppers:Orders for new cars will be very soft for a while

Tank Cars: Ethanol production will surpass 12B gallons in 2010 and chemical output in general is up much higher than expected. Car surpluses should go away in 2010.

Refrigerated Cars: Cost/Benefit mismatch

Railcar Developments

May 20, 2010

Railcar market continues to be misunderstood

Wilbur Ross’s private equity firm recently purchased 4,000 railcars for around $230M and gave the management contract for the cars to Greenbrier, its rail industry partner. In a press release, Ross said that last year one third of all railcars were idle and that this year that figure has been cut in half. He is partially mistaken. While the real numbers may look better, the situation is much worse and a recovery in the leasing market for most car types is a long way off.

http://www.glgroup.com/Council-Member/Toby-Kolstad-85066.html?obj=search&Keyword=kolstad

May 15, 2010

New railcar delivery forecast may be too optimistic

Some forecasters are predicting that new railcar production will climb back to normal levels within a few years. That is a hopeful goal, but the problems affecting two major car types that historically have accounted for 60% of the new railcar market may put it out of reach. Demand for coal and imported goods (not including oil) may take a little longer to recover than the forecasts envision.

http://www.glgroup.com/Council-Member/Toby-Kolstad-85066.html?obj=search&Keyword=kolstad

March 2, 2010

How does a 15% decline in traffic idle 30% of railcar fleet?

There are approximately 1.6 million railcars in North America, and various reports have shown over a third of them to be surplus to the needs of the railroad industry or its shippers during the past year. Traffic only declined 15% during the year, and there were only a few surplus cars before the recession began, so where did all the surplus equipment arise?

http://www.glgroup.com/Council-Member/Toby-Kolstad-85066.html?obj=search&Keyword=kolstad

March 2, 2010

Odds & Ends

CN ordered 400 new boxcars and 750 new gondola cars from National Steel at the end of the year for its own fleet, and CSX ordered 3,000 coal cars from FreightCar America for delivery in 2010 and 2011. The orders only provided confirmation that deliveries will be clost to 14,000 cars in 2010, despite the low level of backlogged orders at the start of the  year.

Ethanol production is running at an annual rate 12B gallons and most tank cars that have been built for that industry should be in active service by the end of the year, if not sooner. The same should be true for the jumbo covered hoppers built for the DDG byproduct.

Grain traffic is also back up and the surplus fleet of large covered hoppers should be disappearing. If farmers plant another bumper crop this summer and exports hold up, the surplus should soon disappear. Orders for new cars might be here sooner than expected.

March 2, 2010

New Car Stats

The tables for the 3rd and 4th quarters didn't look appreciably different than the one posted on September 8th, although deliveries declined thoughout the year and ended up south of 22,000 cars, almost matching the forecasts made at the start of the year. The fourth quarter table will be posted next month.

September 8 , 2009

New Car Stats

2009

2nd Qrt

2nd Qrt

2nd Qrt

YTD-09

YTD-09

 

ORDERS

DELIVERIES

BACKLOG

ORDERS

DELIVERIES

BOX CARS

35

100

35

135

353

COVERED HOPPERS

  Over 5500 c/f

19

213

18

204

720

  3500-5500 c/f

315

769

4944

622

1724

  Under 3500 cf

44

501

952

393

817

OPEN-TOP HOPPERS

  Steel

1

258

750

101

544

  Aluminum

85

1044

399

95

2684

GONDOLAS

  GB Steel

0

224

254

60

771

  GT Steel

155

0

155

155

0

  GT Aluminum

673

856

1391

925

1027

FLAT CARS

  Non-intermodal

0

112

438

0

196

  Intermodal:

  Non-Articulated

0

0

0

0

0

  Articulated

  5-Unit Platforms

                   
0
0
0

0

0

  Other Platforms

0
0

0

0

0

TANK CARS

838

2386

12222

1848

5291

OTHER CARS
0
0
0
0
0

TOTALS

2165

6463

21558

4538

14127

May 7 , 2009

New Car Deliveries/Orders/Backlogs for the 1Q09

New railcar deliveries in the first quarter of 2009 fell to 7,657 cars, down sharply from the 14,459 cars produced in the fourth quarter of 2008. The falloff in deliveries shows rather dramatically the effect of the Economic Stimulus Package of 2008 which contained an accelerated depreciation option for new rail assets purchased before Dec. 31, 2009. Unfortunately, many of the railcars might have been delivered in 2009 and the decrease in production might not have been as great in 2009 as is now expected.

Only 2,374 new railcars were ordered compared with 4,259 cars in the fourth quarter, confirming expectations that production will keep falling throughout 2009 and into 2010. This industry has a long way to fall before the bottom of the trough is reached in this business cycle.

 

March 16 , 2009

New Car Stats

2008

4th Qrt

4th Qrt

4th Qrt

YTD-07

YTD-07

 

ORDERS

DELIVERIES

BACKLOG

ORDERS

DELIVERIES

BOX CARS

0

147

253

0

147

COVERED HOPPERS

  Over 5500 c/f

99

688

534

2232

4266

  3500-5500 c/f

966

2320

6585

7171

10025

  Under 3500 cf

260

350

837

1545

2482

OPEN-TOP HOPPERS

  Steel

274

423

1194

1376

3413

  Aluminum

550

2507

2948

5160

5489

GONDOLAS

  GB Steel

40

791

965

2301

1834

  GT Steel

0

1070

0

1870

2375

  GT Aluminum

1109

788

1491

3896

4391

FLAT CARS

  Non-intermodal

0

298

684

1383

1839

  Intermodal:

  Non-Articulated

0

0

0

20

220

  Articulated

  5-Unit Platforms

                   
0
0
0

0

0

  Other Platforms

0
0

0

1101

1281

TANK CARS

961

5077

16430

5180

21700

OTHER CARS
0
0
0
0
0

TOTALS

4259

14459

31921

33235

59954

October 6 , 2008

Railcar deliveries will fall again in 2009 by a significant amount

The stock prices of all railcar builders declined after a recent prediction by a KeyBank analyst that railcar deliveries will fall in 2009. He estimated that deliveries in 2009 would fall to around 37,000 cars from the 45,000 to 50,000 cars expected this year. It is hard to argue with this forecast except that it might be a little too optimistic if there is a severe economic contraction in 2009. However, several more weeks will be needed before such a dreary scenario can be painted.

http://www.glgroup.com/Council-Member/Toby-Kolstad-85066.html?obj=search&Keyword=kolstad

 

June 11 , 2008

Production of coal cars may not significantly increase in future

There is much hope that orders for new coal cars will increase in the near future, lifting production rates at Freightcar America (RAIL). Coal exports are up almost 80% from a few years ago and domestic demand should increase significantly when the 52 new coal-fired generating plants which are currently under construction come online. The latter are expected to require about 20,000 railcars to move coal from the mines to the utilities. Coal production is up 1.1% in 2008 and railcar loads are up 3.1% through July. So why are orders for new cars so low?

http://www.glgroup.com/Council-Member/Toby-Kolstad-85066.html?obj=search&Keyword=kolstad

June 11 , 2008

Leasing companies order and/or buy railcars, not railroad companies; and therein lays the problem

The in Forbes article about the large number of surplus railcars, the author incorrectly blames the railroad companies for stocking up on ethanol cars until the “ethanol bubble burst” and they realized they had built too many cars. In truth, railcar leasing companies ordered the cars after hearing requests and projections by ethanol companies about the need for more equipment to handle future production from new capacity that was either planned or already under construction. That new capacity is still coming online, albeit at a pace much slower than originally expected, and there may be a few thousand “surplus” cars until production catches up with car supply in 2009.  The ethanol phenomenon has mitigated some of the other problems faced by the railcar industry that can be more correctly blamed on the railroads.

http://www.glgroup.com/Council-Member/Toby-Kolstad-85066.html?obj=search&Keyword=kolstad

May 8 , 2008

The first quarter's new railcar order-delivery-backlog report was finally issued.

Orders fell to 10,484, deliveries held to around 14,000 cars, and backlogs fell to around 65,000 cars due to the cancellation of many orders for intermodal and ethanol equipment. More details will follow at a later date.

March 27 , 2008

Limited ethanol distribution channels and slowing production growth means surplus railroad tank cars

Two years ago, the ethanol industry went into overdrive in expanding production facilities and ordering railroad tank cars to move the expected flood of new production. No one, however, looked at how the ethanol was to be handled at the customer end of the distribution network and that has produced a major problem for the new industry. Even with corn prices well above $5.00 per bushel, ethanol producers could make about $0.20/per gallon if they could get their product to the final customer, the US motorist. Unfortunately, there are only four terminals ready to handle unit trains of ethanol and the shipment of small carload lots is just too slow to move the expected production. Tank car lessors who ordered large numbers of railcars to move ethanol have been left holding the bag this time waiting for the gasoline distributors to get with the program. http://www.glgroup.com/Council-Member/Toby-Kolstad-85066.html?obj=search&Keyword=kolstad

February 20, 2008

Car Totals

2007

4th Qrt

4th Qrt

4th Qrt

YTD-07

YTD-07

 

ORDERS

DELIVERIES

BACKLOG

ORDERS

DELIVERIES

BOX CARS

60

60

400

560

222

COVERED HOPPERS

         

  Over 5500 c/f

637

1903

8568

4226

8005

  3500-5500 c/f

6081

2026

9886

7591

8122

  Under 3500 cf

632

914

1217

1828

4313

OPEN-TOP HOPPERS

       

  Steel

344

518

3338

3195

1413

  Aluminum

2158

658

3229

4174

4968

GONDOLAS

         

  GB Steel

324

371

498

350

2415

  GT Steel

400

256

400

400

1200

  GT Aluminum

1225

1306

1986

2945

5500

FLAT CARS

         

  Non-intermodal

300

348

1158

1150

1628

  Intermodal:

         

  Non-Articulated

0

0

200

200

7

  Articulated

         

  5-Unit Platforms

                    0
1105
5520

2750

3930

  Other Platforms

0
0

0

0

0

TANK CARS

11561

5397

39460

24215

21433

OTHER CARS
0
0
0
0
0

TOTALS

23722

148622

75860

53584

63156

Octobert 25 , 2007

Car Totals

Fourth quarter railcar deliveries amounted to 14, 862 cars, continuing a slow decline in production that started in the beginning of the year. Orders for new equipment reached 23,722 cars, although 11,000 of these are assumed to be related to a reported multi-year order for new tank cars running from 2009 to 2018. Without the latter orders, the quarterly total would have been only 12,722, which is more in line with the RTF forecasts of 48,000 cars in 2008. Car type totals will be published in March, but are now available to anyone who requests them.

Octobert 25 , 2007

Car Totals

Railcar deliveries were projected last fall to total around 61,500 cars for the year ahead, and the reported totals through the 3rd quarter are making that prediction look awfully close right now.

2007

3rd Qrt

3rd Qrt

3rd Qrt

YTD-07

YTD-07

 

ORDERS

DELIVERIES

BACKLOG

ORDERS

DELIVERIES

BOX CARS

0

100

400

500

162

COVERED HOPPERS

         

  Over 5500 c/f

629

2424

9834

3589

6102

  3500-5500 c/f

714

1731

5831

1510

6096

  Under 3500 cf

260

934

1499

1196

3399

OPEN-TOP HOPPERS

       

  Steel

355

251

3512

2851

895

  Aluminum

1342

1344

1729

2016

4310

GONDOLAS

         

  GB Steel

381

247

545

747

2044

  GT Steel

0

378

256

1090

944

  GT Aluminum

351

632

2067

830

4194

FLAT CARS

         

  Non-intermodal

0

412

1206

850

1280

  Intermodal:

         

  Non-Articulated

200

0

200

200

7

  Articulated

         

  5-Unit Platforms

                     200
1175
6625

2750

2825

  Other Platforms

0
0

0

0

0

TANK CARS

3689

5404

33296

12654

16036

OTHER CARS
0
0
0
0
0

TOTALS

8121

15032

67000

30783

48294

 

August 20 , 2007

Car Totals

2007

2nd Qrt

2nd Qrt

2nd Qrt

YTD-07

YTD-07

 

ORDERS

DELIVERIES

BACKLOG

ORDERS

DELIVERIES

BOX CARS

500

0

0

500

62

COVERED HOPPERS

         

  Over 5500 c/f

85

1744

11841

2960

3678

  3500-5500 c/f

540

2181

6436

796

4365

  Under 3500 cf

7

1451

2373

936

2465

OPEN-TOP HOPPERS

       

  Steel

2075

103

3408

2498

644

  Aluminum

631

1132

1731

959

2966

GONDOLAS

         

  GB Steel

6

689

411

366

1797

  GT Steel

0

378

634

0

566

  GT Aluminum

825

1396

2348

1369

3562

FLAT CARS

         

  Non-intermodal

400

414

1618

850

868

  Intermodal:

         

  Non-Articulated

0

7

0

0

7

  Articulated

         

  5-Unit Platforms

                     2290
895
7600

2550

1650

  Other Platforms

0
0

0

0

0

TANK CARS

4236

5760

35011

8965

10632

OTHER CARS
0
0
0
0
0

TOTALS

11595

16143

73911

22747

33262

July 18, 2007

Second quarter ARCI totals.

Railcar orders during the second quarter reached only 11,595 cars, and deliveries fell to 16,143 units. We forecasted the total deliveries for the year will only be about 62,000 cars, and we see no reason to change that prediction. Quarterly deliveries are expected to continue to decline in the second half of the year and to fall even further in 2008. There were very few surprises in the individual car type totals, except for the 500 boxcar orders that were reported. Specific car totals will be posted later.

July 11, 2007

Car Totals

2007

1st Qrt

1st Qrt

1st Qrt

YTD-07

YTD-07

 

ORDERS

DELIVERIES

BACKLOG

ORDERS

DELIVERIES

BOX CARS

0

62

0

0

62

COVERED HOPPERS

         

  Over 5500 c/f

2875

1934

14323

2878

1934

  3500-5500 c/f

256

2184

7584

256

2184

  Under 3500 cf

929

1014

3820

929

1014

OPEN-TOP HOPPERS

       

  Steel

421

541

1436

421

541

  Aluminum

328

1834

2517

328

1834

GONDOLAS

         

  GB Steel

360

1108

1184

360

1108

  GT Steel

0

188

1012

0

188

  GT Aluminum

544

2166

2919

544

2166

FLAT CARS

         

  Non-intermodal

450

454

1632

450

454

  Intermodal:

         

  Non-Articulated

0

7

0

0

7

  Articulated

         

  5-Unit Platforms

260
755
6445

260

755

  Other Platforms

0
0

0

0

0

TANK CARS

4729

4897

36166

30084

10017

OTHER CARS
0
13
17
50
33

TOTALS

11152

17148

79038

11152

17148

 

July 11, 2007

Car Totals

Watch for 2006 totals on later date

Dec. 12, 2006

Car Totals

2006

3rd Qtr

3rd Qtr

3rd Qtr

YTD-06

YTD-065

 

ORDERS

DELIVERIES

BACKLOG

ORDERS

DELIVERIES

BOX CARS

0

482

455

3744

1567

COVERED HOPPERS

         

  Over 5500 c/f

4334

1035

12012

9529

3893

  3500-5500 c/f

1320

2454

11028

9071

5842

  Under 3500 cf

682

1286

4910

3485

4872

OPEN-TOP HOPPERS

       

  Steel

396

798

2244

2254

1034

  Aluminum

329

3040

5890

2925

8208

GONDOLAS

         

  GB Steel

1811

617

2012

3243

2473

  GT Steel

50

50

1300

1350

254

  GT Aluminum

128

2950

5386

1432

8430

FLAT CARS

         

  Non-intermodal

312

334

1782

2712

2859

  Intermodal:

         

  Non-Articulated

7

587

7

1099

1100

  Articulated

         

  5-Unit Platforms

3

1853

6940

8023

6008

  Other Platforms

1

1

1

3

338

TANK CARS

12093

3508

34148

30084

10017

OTHER CARS
0
13
17
50
33

TOTALS

21466

19008

88116

75633

56928

October 26, 2006

Third quarter orders, deliveries, and backlogs

Twelve thousand more tank cars were ordered during the 3Q06, bring the backlog to 34, 148 cars, enough to carry production into 2009 at the current rate and well into 2008 even if production can be ramped up to 18,500 cars in 2007. The ethanol buildup knows no bounds for the present, but the number of cars on order suggests that either the industry is shooting for 12 billion gallons by 2012, or there will be a surplus of tank cars suitable for handling ethanol in a few years. If not for the DDG and grain covered hoper cars and the ethanol tank cars, the orders in the third quarter looked rather poor: (1) very few coal cars; (2) no boxcars and few flatcars; (3) and almost no intermodal cars were ordered. The latter situation is a surprise, given the 6.5% growth in intermodal traffic so far this year. Rumors of a small surplus persist and partially explain the lack of orders, but the traffic will eventually demand more cars.

July 28, 2006

Tank Cars

While orders for most other car types are decreasing, demand for new tank cars far exceeds the production capacity of the new car builders. So far in 2006, over 18,000 cars have been ordered and the backlog at the end of the second quarter was 25,564 cars, over two years production at the current rate of delivery. Only three car builders produce this type of car, and they are the oldest companies in the industry, tracing their roots back to the late 1800s: (1) Union Tank Car is privately owned by the Pritzker family, but (2) Trinity Industries (TRN) and (3) American Railcar (ARII) are public companies. The ARII plant that produces tank cars was damaged by a tornado during the second quarter and full production is not expected to resume until September.

July 28, 2006

Car Totals

2006

1 st Qtr

1st Qtr

1st Qtr

YTD-06

YTD-065

 

ORDERS

DELIVERIES

BACKLOG

ORDERS

DELIVERIES

BOX CARS

294

669

1273

294

669

COVERED HOPPERS

         

  Over 5500 c/f

3315

1802

7936

3315

1802

  3500-5500 c/f

7115

1249

13653

7115

1249

  Under 3500 cf

1876

1515

6635

1876

1515

OPEN-TOP HOPPERS

       

  Steel

1263

98

2189

1263

98

  Aluminum

621

2370

9572

621

2370

GONDOLAS

         

  GB Steel

905

963

1185

906

963

  GT Steel

0

76

126

0

76

  GT Aluminum

405

2500

10121

405

2500

FLAT CARS

         

  Non-intermodal

1300

1240

2019

1300

1240

  Intermodal:

         

  Non-Articulated

1092

0

1100

1092

0

  Articulated

         

  5-Unit Platforms

7000

2380

9546

7000

2380

  Other Platforms

0

336

0

0

336

TANK CARS

10005

3344

20702

10005

3344

OTHER CARS
800
0
800
800
0

TOTALS

35991

18542

86857

35991

18542

May 2, 2006

Coal Cars

In recent testimony before a congressional committee, Matt Rose, the president of BNSF, presented two charts relating to coal traffic on his railroad. In one chart, coal tonnage is shown to rise over 8% during the last few years. In another chart, the number of train sets of coal cars rose over 43% during the same period. Does anyone see something wrong with this comparison? (See graphs at side) Where are all those extra train sets working and will there be enough track space for the deluge of new cars that will be delivered this year. Coal production has continued to rise at an annual rate of 2% during the 1st quarter of 2006, but the 20,000 coal cars that were backlogged for production at the start of the year represented around 10% of the coal cars currently moving in train sets in the US.

 

 

 

 

April 18, 2006

New Car Deliveries, Orders, Backlogs

First Quarter Numbers are surprisingly high, but RTF forecasts for year looks good. Call for updates. Numbers won't be posted until May.

April 18, 2006

Covered Hopper Cars

You can’t make a lot of ethanol without producing tons of dried distiller’s grains (DDGs). More of the stuff is being made than the dairy and beef cattle in the Midwest can handle, so ethanol producers have to ship the feed supplement to distant markets. Past attempts to ship by rail were not that successful due to the small supply of 6200cf jumbo covered hopper cars and the problems with unloading the DDG products.  This must have been resolved because the surge in demand for jumbo covered hopper cars is greater than what might have been expected from plastic pellet producers.

April 13, 2006

Tank Cars

There has been much written and reported by the press and media concerning the shortage of ethanol and the problems with the railroad distribution of this product. The shortage has arisen because ethanol is the only available substitute for MTBE, the oxygenation agent that made unleaded fuels possible. MTBE, which has been banned due to environmental and health problems, was imported by ship to the nation’s refineries which are mostly along the coasts. Ethanol is produced in the Midwest, from where there are no pipelines to gasoline distributors.

 

Tank car producers, (ARI, Union Tank, and Trinity), are rumored to be giving priority to the production of ethanol tank cars, and backlogging some orders for other types of tank cars. Last year 40% of all new tank car deliveries were reported to be for ethanol service. Perhaps the percentage has grown. A reported car shortage has increase tank car lease rates above the levels that might have been expected from their current production costs and the prevailing interest rates.

March 13 , 2005

Car Totals

The ARCI recently released the fourth quarter results from the railcar builders. Demand remains strong for almost all car types, with intermodal cars being the most notable exception. Deliveries increased for again, reflected the grwoing backlog of coal tank cars.

2005

4th Qtr

4th Qrt

4th Qrt

YTD-05

YTD-05

 

ORDERS

DELIVERIES

BACKLOG

ORDERS

DELIVERIES

BOX CARS

959

863

1648

2075

3753

COVERED HOPPERS

         

  Over 5500 c/f

3005

1927

6519

6222

3639

  3500-5500 c/f

4465

1496

7787

6768

7193

  Under 3500 cf

2747

1067

6177

6235

4041

OPEN-TOP HOPPERS

       

  Steel

754

0

1024

1024

65

  Aluminum

4967

2678

11321

12257

9375

GONDOLAS

         

  GB Steel

475

925

1243

2066

2112

  GT Steel

0

0

204

204

0

  GT Aluminum

16651

1252

12216

13057

4752

FLAT CARS

         

  Non-intermodal

400

1403

1959

4363

5675

  Intermodal:

         

  Non-Articulated

80

1

8

80

2662

  Articulated

         

  5-Unit Platforms

0

2640

4925

7950

6855

  Other Platforms

0

690

336

1020

6927

TANK CARS

7124

3033

14041

17271

11563

TOTALS

26569

17975

69408

80520

68612

March 1, 2006

Tank Cars

In the past few years, there have been a number of train derailments involving pressurized tank cars that were damaged enough to allow the release of their hazardous contents. Tragically, the release of the hazmat materials in three such incidents resulted in fatalities. Following the 2002 derailment in Minot ND in which one person died, the FRA conducted a study and found that the tank cars involved had been built before 1989, the year normalized steel was required in all pressurized tank car bodies. In the most recent derailment in Graniteville SC in which 12 people died, the tank car involved had been built in 1993 and was made of normalized steel. The FRA has planned a study of the current fleet of tank cars to see if there is a significant level of risk from the pre-1989 built cars.

 

Ahead of any such study, the AAR has announced that it intends to require the replacement of all pre-1989 built pressurized tank cars in the next 5-7 years. Needless to say, the AAR does not intend to reimburse the owners of such cars for the mandated early retirement. Opposition to this directive is strong and the support for the replacement of the pre-1989 cars in weak; but the AAR does not have to explain or justify its case in a court of law.

 

If this order becomes effective, 37,000 railcars will have to be replaced, adding approximately 6,000 new car builds per year to the normal demand for tank cars. Coupled with a potential demand for a similar number of tank cars to handle the growing needs of ethanol producers, could conceivably raise tank car deliveries to over 20,000 per year during the next several years. That is almost two time the current and very healthy delivery rate.

 

January 19, 2006

Tank Cars

In a recent magazine article, the president of Union Tank Car reported that the 2004/2005/2006 new car totals for tank cars designed to move ethanol are 2,500, 4,000, and 5,000 cars respectively, representing 28%, 34%, and 45% of all new tank car deliveries during those years. Ethanol appears to be the main driver of new additions to the national tank car fleet. Projections for the future production of this fuel vary widely, but the rate of growth in recent years shows no signs of slowing. Consumers appear to favor ethanol blended gasoline over regular gasoline for two reasons: (1) it adds less pollutants to the environment; (2) if cost less per gallon. What they don’t seem to realize is that ethanol gets less miles per gallon than gasoline and the dollars per gallon that is saved at the pump is an illusion since more trips to the pump are necessary with ethanol than with straight gasoline.  There is an extensive review of this product and the implications for new freight car deliveries in the 2006 North American Freight Car Market.

January 11, 2006

Intermodal Cars

CN is looking for 3,000 new doublestack container cars to meet an expected surge in traffic through its Prince Rupert container port in 2006. The traffic is expected to be diverted from other West Coast ports due to logistical savings CN is promising. It is a safe bet with minimum risks since CN can return TTX cars that it currently uses for intermodal traffic if the new Prince Rupert business does not grow as planned. TTX will most likely stay out of the market until demand for their cars becomes more apparent.

December 22, 2005

Intermodal Cars

TTX did not order new intermodal cars during the third quarter and no word has surfaced of any orders during the fourth quarter. As we predicted in our press release this summer, the numbers were not looking good for a continuation of the double digit growth in 2004 and early 2005. At the time, RTF projected a year-over-year gain of only 5.7% for 2005, not too far from the 5.9-6.0% increase expected when the final AAR data is released next month. New car deliveries during 2005 needed a 10% growth in loads to be fully utilized, and as a result of the shortfall, some doublestack cars were reported to be in storage during the normally busy third and fourth quarters. The prospects of increased traffic growth in 2006 are not encouraging at the present time and new car deliveries for the year should fall well short of the total 15,500 total expected for 2005.

 

November 14 , 2005

Car Totals

The ARCI recently released the third quarter results from the railcar builders. Demand remains strong for almost all car types, with intermodal cars being the most notable exception. Also, deliveries did not increase for the first time in several quarters, perhaps signally that the top of the production cycle has been reached.

2005

3rd Qtr

3rd Qtr

3rd Qtr

YTD-05

YTD-05

 

ORDERS

DELIVERIES

BACKLOG

ORDERS

DELIVERIES

BOX CARS

536

898

1544

1116

2898

COVERED HOPPERS

 

 

 

 

 

  Over 5500 c/f

2293

997

5311

2982

1949

  3500-5500 c/f

1000

1573

4741

2349

5827

  Under 3500 cf

2265

1087

4898

3788

2671

OPEN-TOP HOPPERS

 

 

 

 

  Steel

80

0

270

270

65

  Aluminum

3352

2958

9032

7290

6697

GONDOLAS

 

 

 

 

 

  GB Steel

375

459

1693

1591

1187

  GT Steel

204

0

204

204

0

  GT Aluminum

3821

1008

11803

11392

3500

FLAT CARS

 

 

 

 

 

  Non-intermodal

1535

1021

2962

3963

4274

  Intermodal:

 

 

 

 

 

  Non-Articulated

0

421

1

0

2661

  Articulated

 

 

 

 

 

  5-Unit Platforms

0

1950

7565

7950

4215

  Other Platforms

0

1650

1026

1020

6237

TANK CARS

1978

2965

9936

10129

8501

TOTALS

17439

16987

60986

54044

50682

November 3, 2005

Covered Hopper Cars

Ethanol producers are holding the DDG by-product a little long before loading it into railars and also drying the stuff for a little longer. These changes, together with bigger 42"x42” gravity gates, may solve the “caking” problem that has plagued the unloading operations for this product. In any event, orders surged for this car type in the third quarter, and many thousands will be needed if the move to ethanol continues. RTF recently completed a study of this industry and it appears that a new car type, a 6351cf covered hopper with extra large gravity gates, may keep Trinity and their competitors for this product in “high cotton” for quite a while.

 

October 5, 2005

Hopper Cars

The demand for new coal cars seems to have no limit at least as far a traffic growth is concerned. We’ll have to wait for the stats to be published to get a better look, but there are rumors that some old fleets are to be replaced. For many years the Eastern carriers have allowed their fleets of manually discharged hoppers to age and retire without replacement, preferring to let utilities and coal companies acquire rapid discharge hoppers and rotary dump gondola cars for unit train operations. It is rumored that one and perhaps both Eastern carriers are investigating the economics of replacing their aged fleets with newer models.

August 29, 2005

Intermodal Cars

Revised Retail Sales numbers from the Federal Reserve show continued growth at a real (after inflation) rate of approximately 3.25% for the first half of the year. This is less than the inflation adjusted rate of 5.94% for 2004.  Imported merchandize (excluding oil) is the other driver of intermodal loads and the rate of growth for the first half of 2005 is 12.2% compared to a 15.5% rate of growth for all of 2004. In recent weeks, the AAR has reported that intermodal loads have been running approximately 7% ahead of 2004 levels, which is higher than RFT had expected from the decrease in retail sales activity and higher than the 3.5% weekly rate of growth during the second quarter. It is often said that one should not discount the buying habits of the American consumer, but RFT thinks that there will be many bargains this Christmas because retailers have imported more goods than consumers will likely be able to afford. For the present however, if intermodal loads continue to grow at the present rate, TTX will most likely be back at the order window for more doublestack wells.

Aug 8, 2005

Covered Hopper Cars

The 2005 forecasted corn harvest has recently been cut by 16% and that for soybeans by over 10% due the draught in the Midwest, particularly Illinois. This should have a major impact on the demand for covered hopper equipment for the 2005- 2006 grain season. A 10% increase in the corn 2003 production, coupled by an increase in exports reversed a 10 year slide in grain shipments by rail and led to the recent surge in new car orders. A car surplus is almost certain unless the concurrent problems with barge shipments due to low water levels on the Mississippi River cause a diversion of river traffic to the rails. RTF dies not think the latter is very probable.

July 25, 2005

The ARCI recently released the second quarter results from the railcar builders. Demand remains strong for almost all car types, with coal cars and intermodal equipment topping the list.

2005

2nd Qtr

2nd Qtr

2nd Qtr

YTD-05

YTD-05

 

ORDERS

DELIVERIES

BACKLOG

ORDERS

DELIVERIES

BOX CARS

580

767

1906

580

2000

COVERED HOPPERS

 

 

 

 

 

  Over 5500 c/f

422

571

4015

689

952

  3500-5500 c/f

939

2389

5325

1349

4254

  Under 3500 cf

873

986

3719

1523

1584

OPEN-TOP HOPPERS

 

 

 

 

  Steel

7

0

190

190

65

  Aluminum

1710

2352

8638

3938

3739

GONDOLAS

 

 

 

 

 

  GB Steel

678

367

1777

1216

728

  GT Steel

0

0

0

0

0

  GT Aluminum

4549

1059

8990

7571

2492

FLAT CARS

 

 

 

 

 

  Non-intermodal

1218

1697

2448

2428

3253

  Intermodal:

 

 

 

 

 

  Non-Articulated

0

1029

422

0

2240

  Articulated

 

 

 

 

 

  5-Unit Platforms

3450

1360

9515

7950

2265

  Other Platforms

975

2418

2676

1020

4587

TANK CARS

3731

2919

10923

8151

5536

TOTALS

19132

17914

60544

36605

33695

 

July 4, 2005

Non-Intermodal Flatcars

There has been continued demand for new F Type flatcars, including centerbean cars for lumber service, as the housing boom continues into 2005. Utilization rates remain at historically low levels, partially reflecting the long transit times of the increasing number of lumber shipments from Canada. New centerbeam car designs including the depressed deck car for higher dried lumber capacities and the modified centerbeam to improve loading and unloading efficiencies continue the evolution of this car type, but not enough to make to older cars obsolete. If the new coalition of Canadian and U.S. interests groups recently formed to fight the import tariffs on Canadian lumber are successful, even more cars will be required in the future to handle the increased imports of Canadian Lumber.

June 20, 2005

Boxcars

TTX is rumored to be reviewing its purchase options. Car prices are still high, ranging from $80,000 to $100,000, depending on the make and model, and it is assumed that the TTX car hire rates would be high enough to give their Class I owners heartburn. When car hire deprescription was approved by the ICC in 1993, car hire rates were supposed to go up and down according to the supply and demand. During the 1990s when supplies were plentiful, market based car hire rates fell as predicted. Lately however, they are still very low, even though supplies of good Class A cars are getting scarce.

June 6, 2005

Gondola Cars

Steel companies and scrap dealers are complaining about the lack of an adequate number of railcars to haul their traffic this year. The worldwide demand for scrap iron and finished steel products outstripped supply in 2004 and the price of these commodities and products jumped significantly: 100% for scrap and almost 300% for finished steel. Shippers want to get every pound out the door before the price retreats as RTF has predicted, but there are not enough GB type gondola railcars to move the tonnage. This car type is subject to cyclical demand and the major railroads have all but asked the leasing companies, or perhaps they did ask TTX, to take over the ownership and management of the fleet. Railroads enjoyed a car surplus two years ago and private leasing companies were lucky to get 50% of their expected lease revenue for this car type. With no incentive to order new equipment, it is no wonder that the shortage arose. Moreover, with the high price of railcars these days, the railroads did not want to pay the TTX rates that would have been required if that company had purchased more cars for them this year.

May 23, 2005

Intermodal Cars

TTX placed orders with two builders for approximately 3000 new intermodal well cars, bringing the total orders placed so far this year for this car type to around 7,500 cars. If no additional cars are ordered for delivery next year, a car surplus may be avoided if business improves in the second half of the year. RFT is preparing a revised forecast of total intermodal loads for 2005, but more weekly data will be necessary before the short term model can be used with confidence. Retail sales, inflation, and import traffic are all pointing to a 4.5% gain for the year, a figure below the current year-to-year gains reported by the AAR. However, the weekly loadings are not trending as high as the first half gains; a few more weeks of data will be required before a press release with the revised forecasts can be issued.

May 9, 2005

Boxcars

No orders for new boxcars were received during the first quarter, completing the downward spiral that began in the second quarter of last year. As a result, boxcar deliveries are not expected to exceed 3,500 cars during 2005, down from 5,400 cars in 2004. The inflated cost of steel and the resulting high price of new boxcars are no doubt the main reasons for this decline in demand. Orders for new boxcars are dependent upon the car hire or daily use rates for these assets and the main U.S. railroads have steadfastly capped the rates they are willing to pay for the last several years. At today’s prices, the cost of the new cars has finally exceeded what the railroads are willing to pay.

April 25, 2005

Coal Cars

Orders for GT Gons and RD Hoppers totaled over 5,200 cars during the first quarter, outracing deliveries by almost two to one and increasing the backlog of coal cars to 14,788 cars. Coal traffic is growing and new railcar capacity is needed; moreover there are still old steel cars that can be retired. Many of the latter have been pulled from storage to help the railroads contend with the artificial demand that their slow train speeds created.  But the pace of orders for new cars should give both investors and builders pause for concern that a bubble is building and a collapse in lease rates and new car orders similar to what occurred in 1999 may be around the corner. This development is not yet a certainty since the increasing traffic and problematic rail operations are keeping railcar supplies tight. But in the past, lessors have tended to error on the high side in meeting demand and the current situation seems vaguely familiar.

April 11, 2005

Covered Hopper Cars-Grain Size

Railroad car loadings remained high during the first quarter of 2005, albeit with some significant product and movement shifts that may have a significant impact on future car demand. Export shipments by rail to Mexico almost doubled, with the carload increase matching the decrease in carloads delivered to Texas Gulf ports. Perhaps KCS is converting rail/ship grain movements to Mexico via the UP and BNSF to all rail via its NAFTA lines. If so, the cycle times for the cars involved in the switch will increase significantly. The monthly volume might indicate a net increase in demand for approximately 2,000 more cars unless great improvements have been achieved by TFM in moving cars in and out of Mexico.  Soybean shipments have greatly increased over 2004 levels, offsetting the decrease in wheat and corn shipments. It had been feared that export movements might fall across the board in 2005 due to foreign competition that was stunted by drought conditions in 2004..........April 14, 2005 We have been advised that all western carriers are sending grain traffic into Mexico via their rail connections and that there are destinations in Mexico that can handle unit train shipments in a timely manner. Hurray for progress; traffic will grow if cars are handled efficiently and returned quickly.

March 28, 2005

Automotive Multilevel Flatcars

STCC 37 Vehicles and Parts traffic is up slightly in 2005, but there is plenty of uncertainty for this traffic segment due to worries that the price of gas may affect the market for new automobiles and more importantly, the types of railcars that will be needed in the future. RTF has projected an annual demand for over 3,000 new flatcar platforms in the coming years.  On the supply side, Freightcar America’s aluminum multilevel flatcar may finally provide some competition to the standard Thrall/Trinity multilevel autorack that had dominated the market for this car type in the past.

  

March 14, 2005

Intermodal Cars

BNSF placed an order for almost 5000 doublestack wells with Greenbrier last week, with delivery scheduled into 2006. The 13,000 car backlog at the end of last year was expected to equal the total deliveries in 2005, representing a 6% increase in the fleet capacity. Intermodal loadings have been increasing at a slightly higher rate of 9% in recent months, with utilization rates inching up. Demand for more equipment was expected to lead to at least 10,000 or more orders during 2005 and this recent purchase should represent just 40% or less of the total orders.

 

February 14, 2005

Covered Hopper Cars—Grain size

Once again the smart money is betting that there will be a surplus of 4750cf covered hoppers in the future and are selling their cars while they are still under lease. Prices today range between $15,000 and $21,000; the same cars could have been purchased between 2001 and 2004 for around $10,000. Even the latter price was thought too high since the value of future leases was not estimated to be greater than $8,000.

 

February 7, 2005

Coal Cars—Rapid Discharge Hoppers

There had been many speculative orders for coal cars in the past several months, with most of them placed under lease before the actual delivery from the builder.  With line space being filled, “real” orders are developing early due to the need to guarantee timely deliveries. In the unlikely event that train speeds improve and reduce the amount of artificial demand that has been created since 2003 by the longer turn times, a car surplus could develop. It is more probable that the train speeds will not improve until rail traffic begins to fall.

 

January 21, 2004

Boxcars

Orders for new boxcars have plummeted, probably due to the price of steel and the high prices being quoted. A $90,000 TBOX probably does not make economic sense at the discounted daily rates being offered by TTX to its owners, even when the costs are averaged into an investment base including older cars. Other car owners will have a difficult time recovering their costs from offline users paying “market” based car hire rates.

  

October 21, 2004

Covered Hopper Cars

Orders for jumbo covered hopper cars are increasing beyond expectations, with most of the new equipment destined for service on the BNSF. UP is also contributing to the surge in new car orders by refusing to allow OT-5 authority for cars that do not meet the 286k truck standards adopted in July of this year. Should export traffic decline, another surplus of older cars (ca 1980 builds) is almost a certainty.

June 25, 2004
Boxcars
TTX has ordered more cars for next year. Greenbrier recently announced an order for 400 new cars to be delivered next year, and other announcements are sure to follow. Prices could reach near $90,000 for boxcars that were selling for under $70,000 last year. It is likely that only TTX can afford such prices while still holding the line on lease rates.

June 11, 2004
Intermodal developments
CP Rail has recently announced the acquisition of several thousand doublestack well cars to better handle its intermodal traffic. The fact that 2004 trailer loadings are off significantly from 2003 levels, declining ______% through _______, may cast some doubt over the success of the Iron Highway program previously mentioned. The decline is even more significant in view of the high fuel costs for tractor trailers and the increase in trailer traffic on U.S. carriers.

May 28, 2004
Covered Hopper Cars
With the rapid growth of ethanol plants in the Midwest, a need has arisen for a covered hopper car that can handle the solid meal product that is left after the sugars in the grain have fermented into alcohol. Standard grain covered-hopper cars, either the 263k or 286k capacity cars, will reach their cubic volume capacity before hitting their load limit for this relatively light density product, even though the latter is loaded while still containing some moisture. The moisture is reported to present unloading problems, and damage to the gates is possible if rods or poles are used to loosen the material in order to start the material flowing through the gates. Higher capacity cars with volumes in the 6300cf range are being sought for the movement of this product, but questions regarding the market for these cars for the transport of other products and the problems related to unloading the car must be resolved before most operating lessors will be interested in the equipment.

May 14, 2004
Boxcars
A new autoparts boxcar is being jointly developed by Norfolk Southern and National Steel Car of Canada. The car will be 31” higher to accommodate a third tier of racks, and 10” narrower to possibly eliminate the need for rub rails. Other improvements to the doors and roof are also planned. If the cars are actually produced, they will have only one function and there will only be a limited number of shippers and carriers who might use or lease the equipment. When other types of rail cars have been specifically designed to become part of the logistics network of railroad shippers, such as specialty covered hopper cars for carbon black and plastic pellets, tank cars, and flat cars, the cars have been purchased or leased on a long term basis.

April 30, 2004
Intermodal developments
The return of circus ramp loadings for trailers has been heralded by some with the apparent success of the Iron Highway program in Canada. Webtec is advertising a nationwide network of rail lines and highway transit points for standard deck flatcars with collapsible hitches that will be offered to the railroads on a couple and go basis.

 

Products & Services Railroads Return Home Suppliers Press Releases Recent Magazine Articles Contact Us